Best Staffing Agencies in Wisconsin [2024 List]

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
2002	Milwaukee	11 – 50

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

2002

Milwaukee

11 – 50

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
1987	Madison	51 – 200

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

1987

Madison

51 – 200

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
1983	Milwaukee	11 – 50

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

1983

Milwaukee

11 – 50

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
–	Milwaukee	10001 –

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

–

Milwaukee

10001 –

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
–	Brookfield	51 – 200

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

–

Brookfield

51 – 200

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
2005	Appleton	201 – 500

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

2005

Appleton

201 – 500

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
1995	Appleton	1001 – 5000

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

1995

Appleton

1001 – 5000

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
1996	Milwaukee	1001 – 5000

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

1996

Milwaukee

1001 – 5000

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
1986	Milwaukee	11 – 50

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

1986

Milwaukee

11 – 50

Founding Year	Headquarters	Company Size
1995	Appleton	501 – 1000

Founding Year

Headquarters

Company Size

1995

Appleton

501 – 1000

FAQs

What is a staffing agency?
A staffing agency typically connects businesses with job seekers, catering to a range of employment needs. These can include temporary roles with specific time frames, temp-to-hire positions that may lead to permanent employment, and direct-hire roles where the agency functions more like a traditional recruiter.
Agencies often have a pool of candidates ready, but if a suitable match isn’t immediately available, they broaden their search. This might involve advertising on job boards or utilizing networks like LinkedIn, particularly for specialized or niche roles.
The agency typically handles the recruitment process, but practices can vary. In most cases, the agency employs the candidate, managing payroll and benefits, except in direct hire situations where the hiring company takes over. It’s important to remember that each agency’s approach can differ, tailored to the specific needs of businesses and job seekers.
What are the benefits of staffing agencies?
Staffing agencies bring efficiency to recruitment by handling time-consuming tasks, freeing up your team to focus on core business activities. They are particularly adept at specialized hiring, filling roles with hard-to-find skill sets, which is crucial in today’s market where many employers face a skills gap. These agencies have deep networks and access to passive candidates, enhancing your chances of finding the ideal match. Moreover, they manage legal and financial employment responsibilities, significantly reducing your risk. This includes compliance with labor laws and handling employment-related taxes and insurance, providing peace of mind and operational ease.
Are staffing agencies worth it?
Staffing agencies can be a real asset, especially when you’re looking to fill positions quickly and efficiently. These agencies handle the complexities of recruitment, from sourcing to screening candidates, significantly easing your team’s workload. While there’s a cost involved, the value they bring in finding the right talent often justifies the expense. A key benefit is their handling of employment laws and regulations, ensuring compliance and reducing your legal risks. To get the best fit for your company culture, consider combining their expertise with your internal evaluation. In short, a staffing agency can be a smart investment, aligning with your business needs and contributing to your organization’s success.
What questions should I ask when choosing a staffing agency?
When selecting a staffing agency, it’s crucial to ask the right questions to ensure they align with your company’s hiring needs. Here are key questions to guide your discussion:
1. How do you source and vet top talent, and what is your screening process?
2. Can you describe a typical hiring timeline and your involvement in the process?
3. What guarantees do you offer for the placements you make?
4. How do you support workers after they are placed?
5. What strategies do you use for strong employee retention?
6. Could you explain your follow-up and communication process during recruitment?
7. How do you handle diversity and inclusion in your recruitment process?
8. In what ways can you add value to our internal HR team?
9. What sets you apart from other staffing agencies in the industry?
These questions will help gauge the staffing agency’s capabilities.
How can you review the staffing agency’s record with previous clients?
It’s important to look beyond the testimonials they provide. While these can be informative, they are often curated to show the staffing agency in the best light. You can try directly contacting the agency’s past clients. This way, you can get honest feedback about their experiences with the agency.
You can also leverage independent review platforms for a broader perspective. Websites like Glassdoor and TrustRadius, or industry-specific sites like Best Staffing Agencies, offer reviews and ratings from a variety of sources. These platforms can reveal common themes in client feedback, both positive and negative, giving you a more comprehensive understanding of the agency’s performance and reliability.
How do staffing agencies work?
Working with a staffing agency typically involves these steps:
1. Initial contact: You reach out to an agency specializing in your industry, detailing the job role, number of workers needed, hiring timeline, and pay scale.
2. Job description and advertising: The agency drafts a job description and advertises it. They may also directly contact suitable candidates.
3. Candidate vetting: The agency reviews applications, conducts interviews, and selects qualified candidates for your review.
4. Employer’s final decision: You, as the hiring manager, interview the top candidates from the agency and make the final hiring decision.
5. Paperwork management: The agency handles all new hire paperwork, including contracts, taxes, and payroll tasks.
How much do staffing agencies charge?
Staffing agencies typically have different fee structures depending on the type of hiring. The percentage fee, often a markup on the employee’s wages, is commonly used for temporary and temp-to-hire positions. For direct hire or permanent placements, agencies might charge a one-time fee, which is usually a percentage of the employee’s annual salary.
It’s important to note that these fees can vary based on the industry, the complexity of the role, and the level of expertise required. Additionally, some agencies may have separate fees for other services, like filling a position or contract buyout fees for transitioning a temporary worker to a permanent role.
Why do companies hire through staffing agencies?
Companies opt for staffing agencies primarily for their ability to quickly source qualified candidates, particularly for specialized or urgent roles. This ensures that businesses can fill positions effectively without compromising on quality. Additionally, staffing agencies offer versatile staffing solutions, adapting to various employment needs, whether it’s for short-term projects, trial periods leading to permanent employment, or direct, long-term placements. This flexibility allows companies to respond dynamically to their changing staffing needs while maintaining operational efficiency.

High-Demand Jobs in Wisconsin

Wisconsin’s job market is diverse, with several sectors experiencing high demand for skilled professionals. Key roles include:

Registered nurses: In Wisconsin, registered nurses are highly valued for their critical thinking and compassion. These skills are essential in various healthcare settings, where they provide patient care, support medical procedures, and contribute to health management strategies.
Truck drivers: Professionals in this role are crucial in the transportation and distribution sectors. Their skills in logistics and time management ensure the efficient and safe delivery of goods, playing a vital role in maintaining supply chains and supporting commerce.
Wholesale and manufacturing sales representatives: These individuals are key players in sales and client relations. Their strong communication and negotiation skills are crucial for building client relationships, understanding customer needs, and driving sales growth in various industries.
General and operations managers: With their leadership and organizational skills, these managers are adaptable to any sector that requires operational oversight. They are responsible for planning, directing, and coordinating operations, ensuring efficiency and effectiveness in organizational processes.
Software developers, QA analysts, and testers: In the growing tech industry, these professionals are highly sought after for their technical proficiency and problem-solving skills. They are instrumental in developing software solutions, ensuring quality, and testing products for functionality and user experience.
Human resources specialists: These specialists bring expertise in personnel management and are applicable in all industries for workforce development. Their role in recruiting, training, and managing employee relations is essential for building a strong and effective workforce.

What You Need to Know About the Wisconsin Job Market

Wisconsin’s job market is robust, with several key trends to consider:

Job openings: Wisconsin’s job market shows a strong demand for labor. The state’s total nonfarm employment as of November 2023 is 3,020,300, reflecting ongoing job creation across various sectors.
Sector-specific trends: Key sectors contributing to employment growth include manufacturing, with 479,200 jobs, and education and health services, with 475,900 jobs. The leisure and hospitality sector also shows growth, with 278,800 jobs, indicating a recovery and expansion in these areas.
Competitive environment: Wisconsin’s unemployment rate as of November 2023 is 3.3%, slightly higher than previous months but still indicative of a competitive job market. This environment suggests that employers may need to offer attractive packages to attract and retain top talent.
Economic indicators: The growth in job openings and steady employment rates are positive indicators of Wisconsin’s economic health. The state’s job market is dynamic, with manufacturing and healthcare continuing to be key growth areas.

For those navigating Wisconsin’s job market, understanding these trends is crucial for aligning recruitment strategies with the state’s evolving economic landscape.

Our Methodology

Why Trust Our Listings?

In the quest to bridge the gap between talent acquisition experts and premier staffing agencies, we’ve developed a rigorous selection process. Our methodology ensures that only the most competent and reliable agencies make it to our list. Here’s what sets our selection apart:

Industry Specialization:

We value agencies with deep expertise in specific sectors like technology, healthcare, or finance. Their specialized knowledge ensures services are precisely tailored to your unique needs.

Innovative Sourcing Techniques:

In a dynamic job market, the majority of our chosen agencies stand out for their creative talent sourcing. They skillfully use digital tools and social media to connect you with the finest candidates.

Technological Integration:

Our selected agencies harness technology for smoother operations. From efficient candidate tracking to streamlined communication, they bring modern solutions to traditional staffing challenges.

Client and Candidate Feedback:

We prioritize agencies that listen. By actively seeking and responding to feedback from clients and candidates, they demonstrate a commitment to service excellence and continual improvement.

Methodology

We considered the leading 10 cities in Wisconsin, namely Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Kenosha, Racine, Appleton, Waukesha, Oshkosh, Eau Claire, and Janesville in order to provide you with a curated selection of the leading staffing agencies.

Cookie	Duration	Description
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional	11 months	The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy	11 months	The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.

Best Staffing Agencies in Wisconsin